Your browser's security settings have disabled Javascript, which is required to use this web site effectively.
Please alter your security settings. Click here to see how.

The Brotherhood of Thieves

1 review

23 Broad Street Nantucket, MA 02554

(508) 228-2551


Categories: Casual Dining

About The Brotherhood of Thieves...The bar downstairs gives the The Old Brotherhood the feel of a quintessential meeting place. Upstairs are five separate dining areas with many options for groups of all sizes as well as a bar overlooking Broad Street. The entire food menu is offered on the patio.

Reviews (1 review total)

Framingham, MA
4 reviews
Member since: Mar 2011

Cozy and comfortable charm

We stopped for a burger and a brew on a Sunday before catching our mid-afternoon ferry back to Hyannis. Our table for five was in a cozy back corner, perfect for reminiscing over our wonderful weekend of women's hockey on Nantucket. The service was cheerful and attentive without being obtrusive, though I do wish they'd said something about how their amazing French Onion soup could serve as a meal in itself.

View larger map
Find a place to stay

Nantucket town Rentals | Nantucket Rentals

Browse things to do in Nantucket

Activities |

Other Casual Dining

Save as Favorite

Save this listing to My Favorite Businesses for future reference, help planning your trip, and printing.


Report a Review Issue

Please explain the problem with this review.