Where are some great restaurants on the Cape that offer fall menus? Where do you take visiting guests for a great meal?
My in-laws are arriving soon, and together we will celebrate their 50th wedding anniversary. In thinking about where to take them, we realized that a couple of our favorite places are no longer open in November. After doing some research, we discovered a long list of restaurants that are not only open, but serving special fall menus.
Here are a few places where we have dined and enjoyed a fantastic off-season meal. You can see a list of
Cape Cod Restaurants on our Vacation Planner.
![]()
Mahoney's Atlantic on Main Street in Orleans has one of the greatest bar areas on the Cape! We always choose to sit in the spacious, attractive bar area to enjoy incredible Tuna Sashimi. Open 7 days a week, serving dinner at 5pm, Mahoney's offers a fall menu.
![]()
B & B Pizza on Seaboard Lane in Hyannis has quickly become our go-to place for last minute dinner. Of course they do great pizza. But Mama Bout’s lasagna is great and big enough for two. And, few people know that they have the best Steak Tips…the way you like them. Here's their
pizza menu, and they are open Sunday-Thursday 11:30 a.m till 11:00 p.m. and Friday and Saturday 11:30 a.m. to 1:00 a.m.
![]()
The Brewster Fish House on Main Street is a gem. We have enjoyed many meals here - both lunch and dinner. Quaint setting, friendly servers, and exceptional food. I always order the scallops. This time of year, they are open for Lunch: Wednesday – Monday From 11:30 AM – 3:00 PM and Dinner: Wednesday – Monday From 5PM – 9:30 PM. Check out their Fall menu, and try the lobster bisque!
![]()
PB Boulangerie Bistro in Wellfleet is a must-visit restaurant and bakery. We enjoyed brunch there last year and it blew our minds. Fancy and French, the food is memorable. PB offers Dinner Friday and Saturday 5pm - 10pm: Sunday Brunch 10:00 AM - 2:00 PM and the
Bakery is Open everyday 7am - 7pm - stop by for a croissant!
![]()
Kelly’s on Main in Hyannis rewards the local patrons this time of year with $5.00 burger night every Wednesday. And, they do a great job the rest of the week with great
flatbreads, sandwiches and specials. A great place to watch sports and take in local entertainment. Visit Monday: 4:30pm - Mignight; Tuesday - Thursday: 4:30pm - 1:00am; Friday - Sunday: 11:30am - 1:00am. We may see you there on a Wednesday!
![]()
In the fall and winter, The Belfry Inn & Bistro on Jarves Street in Sandwich is warm and cozy and the menu offers a variety of soups and stews, autumn vegetables, seafood, and roasted meats. Dine by candlelight near a glowing fire as piano music plays softly in the background. Very romantic atmosphere! Hours: Tuesday - Saturday: 5 pm to 9 pm; Wednesday - Saturday: 11:30 am to 3 pm.
Where is your favorite place to dine on the Cape or Islands? Let us know by writing a review on our Dining pages.