How to Handle Trash at Your Cape Cod, Martha’s Vineyard, or Nantucket Vacation Rental

Whether your rental property is on Cape Cod, Martha’s Vineyard, or Nantucket, being mindful of how trash is handled is more important than ever. Overflowing bins and unclear instructions can lead to guest complaints—and even pest problems. These simple steps will help you manage trash, recycling, and compost like a pro, improve guest satisfaction, and keep your coastal home eco-friendly.

Provide Clear Options: Trash, Recycle, Compost

• Clearly label indoor bins with lids for trash, recycling, and compost.
• Don’t skip recycling—guests expect it, especially in environmentally conscious areas like the Cape and Islands.
• Composting is easier than ever in many Massachusetts towns. It’s also one of the best ways to eliminate "smelly trash bags."
• Post printed instructions and signs. We recommend these printable signs from Black Earth Compost.

Pickup Schedules & Bin Sizes Matter

• Consider extra recycling bins for larger homes or multi-family rentals. Common sizes:
• Arrange for multiple pickups per week during peak season.
• Use oversized bins when possible to prevent overflow (and local wildlife invasions).

Pickups vs. Drop-Offs

• Guests are on vacation—don’t make them haul trash to a transfer station.
• Arrange curbside or yard pickup with your waste provider.
• Yard pickup is best: the hauler collects bins without relying on guests.
• Curbside pickup is still great—just be sure bins are placed correctly and regularly.

Maintain Bins Regularly

• Inspect bins weekly for leftover trash, maggots, ants, or animal damage.
• Wash bins at least once a year with soap and water.
• Use a brick or heavy object to secure lids (but avoid bungee cords—they’re dangerous for waste haulers).

Reduce Waste, Save Money

• Provide a filtered water pitcher to cut back on plastic bottles.
• Encourage composting when available—it significantly reduces trash volume.
• Offer reusable shopping bags to limit paper bag overflow in recycling.

A Cleaner Stay = Better Reviews

Guests love staying in well-managed, eco-conscious homes. Whether your property is a charming cottage in Falmouth, a beachside escape on Martha’s Vineyard, or a luxurious retreat in Nantucket, these waste management tips show your commitment to a great guest experience and a healthier planet.

Final Tip

Looking for more tips on managing your Cape Cod vacation rental or improving your guest reviews on the Vineyard or Nantucket? Explore our other host resources or reach out for local service provider recommendations.