Your browser's security settings have disabled Javascript, which is required to use this web site effectively.
Please alter your security settings. Click here to see how.

The Brewster Fish House

5 reviews

2208 Main Street Brewster, MA 02631 View Map

(508) 896-7867

menu $$ 

Categories: Casual Dining

About The Brewster Fish House...“ Always fabulous, sometimes even sublime; attentive service” raves Zagat (2011/2012) The menu changes seasonally to reflect the best of local produce and fish; to which our fiercely loyal clientele will attest. Vegetarian , beef, and gluten free alternatives are available. An eclectic wine list and Specialty cocktails compliment the menu. We are Open for lunch& dinner year round. Named “ Cape’s Best Restaurant/Bistro” two years in a row by Boston Magazine. No reservations please.

Reviews (5 reviews total)

Westfield, NJ
2 reviews
Member since: Oct 2012

Great food, but no reservations

This is one of my favorite restaurants in teh Brewster / Orleans area.
If only they woudl take resrvations, as dining anytime after five or so means a very long wait.......
The food is worth it if you are in no hurry, though!

Brewster, MA
1 review
Member since: Mar 2012

Zagat Rating Well deserved

I loved the local casual feel, but with a fine dining menu! I had the Monkfish and it was amazing. You will not be disappointed, but get there fast, as they do not accept reservations. It's worth every minute, plus they have a great bar !

Dennis, MA
21 reviews
Member since: May 2016

My Favorite Cape Cod Restaurant!

The fish dishes at The Brewster Fish House are the best on Cape Cod, and the service is friendly and efficient. They do not take reservations, so come early (or come for lunch!). It can be crowded, but it is well worth the wait. Simply the best!!

2 reviews
Member since: Oct 2021

Best Restaurant in Brewster

I love this place. It's not just the food, it's also the ambiance and the service--the whole package. The tables are placed tight together which gives the meal an intimate feeling. I have consistently had excellent fresh fish dishes and would recommend the restaurant to anyone.

It's walk-in only so be prepared for a 45 minute wait. And it's pricey.

Brewster, MA
19 reviews
Member since: Jun 2011

Inventive American cuisine, but a bit overpriced

Best calamari on the Cape. Can't go wrong with the meals here - they've got a fantastic, creative chef. But it's a bit pricy, it's crowded even with the new addition, and they don't take reservations, so unless Mom and Dad are watching the kids, we go elsewhere.

Find a place to stay

Brewster Rentals | Cape Cod Rentals

Browse things to do in Brewster

Dining | Activities | Shopping | Arts | Fitness

Other Casual Dining


Save as Favorite

Save this listing to My Favorite Businesses for future reference, help planning your trip, and printing.


Report a Review Issue

Please explain the problem with this review.