We recently spent 2 weeks at this house. The house is quite spacious and has a well stocked kitchen with modern appliances. The house is in a very private spot and this worked out very well for us, having a large dog with us. The downstairs can be humid, but there is an efficient constantly-running dehumidifier(there was no mold or excessive mustiness). There are 3 bathrooms as well as an outdoor shower, which we used regularly.
The house does not have A/C and on very hot days it can get hot, but there are ample fans throughout the house and we found that the majority of the time we were comfortable. There was often a lovely breeze from the ocean.
The deck has spectacular views, overlooking Menemsha pond and the open ocean beyond it. We saw varied birds including white egrets, herons and even deer in the early morning. We ate most meals on the deck and were able to totally relax there.
There is a small beach on Menemsha pond, which is a 5 minute walk from the house. At first, we thought we would mainly go to the main ocean beach, Lucy Vincent, but we found that the pond beach was a very peaceful spot and we often swam there with our dog and rented kayaks and paddled in the pond. We did obtain passes for Lucy Vincent beach, which is a beautiful ocean beach with nice surf (no dogs allowed during summer months). The pass includes access to Squibnocket beach, but we did not make it there.
We have stayed in "fancier" houses, but there is something very special about this house that leads us to highly recommend a stay there. The privacy, the beautiful views from deck, the nearby beach on the pond are all hard to beat. We also found that the owners were very cordial via email and receptive to any inquiries.