My wife and I rented the house for 2 weeks and had a fantastic time! The house is very well stocked/equipped with everything needed, including food and water bowls for our dog, which was a nice touch. The layout is great, with one bedroom/bath downstairs, and the other bedrooms and bath upstairs at the opposite end of the house. We had some friends join us for a few days, but the layout gave us all privacy. The yard is HUGE, and we spent quite a bit of time out there with our dog.
The location worked really well for us. It is just down the street from Tradewinds preserve where we took the dog for a hike almost every morning (off leash!), and it is a short walk to downtown Oak Bluffs by way of the gingerbread cottages. We coordinated everything with Ellen. She was very responsive while we made the plans, and checked in to make sure we had everything we needed after we arrived. We would definitely stay there again.